These fact patterns are copyrighted by the Law, Youth & Citizenship Program of the New York State Bar Association.  They are available for classroom use.

If the case is to be used for a tournament, please send a written request to

Please be advised that these materials CANNOT be used for any tournaments that charge a fee for participation.

NOTE:  The Rules of Evidence were updated in 2014.  If you are using any of the cases prior to the 2014 case, please download the most current version of the Rules of Evidence, dated 11/19/14. You need to replace the Rules of Evidence in those cases with the most current version.

Click here to download the most current version of the Rules of Evidence.

2016 - People v Kelly Roberts

2015 - Morningside Heights Booster Club Inc v Casey Cheatham

2014 - People of the State of New York vs.Penn HydraGas, Inc. and Mitchell Tomley, CEO

2013 - Morgan Martin vs. Cattaraugus Programming University  

2012 - State of New York v P.J. Long 

2011 - Pat Parker v Village of Empireville and Board of Trustees of the Village of Empireville 

2010 - State of New York v Shawn Miller 

2009 - Chris Cross v Randy E. Porter 

2008 - Ryan Strongarm v Chris Rocket

2007 - State of New York v Pat C. Macintosh

2006 - State of New York v Terry C. O'Neal

2005 - Macca Elery McLaughlin v Lee and Robbie McLaughlin

2004 - Jo Moncrieff v WSUB-TV, Lee Juno

2003 - State of New York v C. C. Rider

2002 - Sandy and Pat Loam v The National Overland-Youngstown Bank

2001 - State of New York v Monk Agricultural Chemical Co., Taylor and Jefferson Monk

2000 - State of New York v Mickey Jackson

1999 - State of New York v Brandon Berry

1998 - State of New York v Josie Winters

1997 - Jamie June v Dry Gulch Public School District

1996 - Morgan and Jan Crewshank v Jody, Mickey and Rudi Ramirez

All materials property of NYSBA.